Musings from The Software Underground

I'm not sure how others have found the App Store approval to be, but I found it anything but smooth. In trying to get MacGourmet touch approved for the App Store, it was rejected three times:

• The first rejection, 3 days after submission, was because I didn't acknowledge that there might not be an active connection available. OK, I've noticed that other apps don't necessarily do this, but I found the reference, sort of, so fine, it's a logical request. Resubmit.


• The second rejection, 3 days after resubmission, was because I didn't provide "login information" for testing... which shows a lack of understanding about syncing that the average MacGourmet user wouldn't share. Syncing is with the app, not a web site that requires a username/password... Fine, I provided a download link for the prerelease of 2.4 and a link to the set up instructions. Resubmit.


• The third rejection, after another 3 days, was the result of the wrong build hastily getting placed on the server. A 30 second fix. Turn around time on that one? 4 days.

As a developer who is used to complete control over my release schedule, and when products are "ready for release", this whole exercise is an exercise in frustration. Not to mention, the whole process is time consuming. 3 days for each turnaround, which is probably decent, is just too long. Does everyone experience this kind of submission experience? I'll bet that once Apple decided to relax their standards and let iFart into the store, that it wasn't rejected even once...

There IS a flip side supposedly too though, as detailed here: Android app uproar sparks debate over open app store model. Apparently an app store can be a little TOO loose, at least according to the writer, who advocates needing submission standards similar to Apple's. Really, though, how is software downloaded from the Android app store different from software you can download and install now for your Mac or PC? These problems are all possible when you download a Mac application, but you hope that the developers are good citizens and do their best to "do no harm" and for the most part, that works.

As you can see, the problems with the App Store go beyond just what Craig Hockeberry refers to in his open letter to Steve Jobs, Ringtone apps. Anything more complicated than a fart "Ringtone app" is bound to also be a LOT more difficult to get approved, if for no other reason than the testers don't read or misunderstand requirements, and don't know how to use the companion apps the iPhone apps are made to work with.

Add to that, it's getting harder and harder to make a compelling business reason to even produce apps for the store, at least anything beyond what you can develop quickly and sell for a buck: The future of the crApp Store as detailed by the folks at Chilli X.

Now that MacGourmet touch is out, I do plan to add to it, but I'll have to balance that time with development on the main MacGourmet product and I have no choice but to base that time on what MacGourmet touch can generate for revenue. I love developing for the Mac, don't get me wrong, and that extends to the iPhone, but everything has a cost, and if the App Store doesn't have a significant enough return on time investment, then I'll have to spend a larger bulk of my time every day elsewhere.

MacGourmet 2.4, a free minor update, is now available.

This version adds support for syncing your information with your iPhone/iPod touch using MacGourmet touch, available very soon exclusively from the iPhone App Store. For a full list of changes, please see the release notes.

As always, MacGourmet can be downloaded from the MacGourmet download page or by using the built-in software update service.

MacGourmet Deluxe version 1.1, which includes MacGourmet 2.4, can be downloaded from the Mariner Software download page as soon as they make it available.

This new release is primarily targeted at the iPhone/iPod touch support so, what, you may be wondering, is coming next? I plan to have long overdue updates for Mealplan, Cookbook and Nutrition out before too long, changes are already underway, hopefully due out over the next month or so. They've seen a delay because of how much work developing MacGourmet touch took.

Then, after that, it's head down and into development for version 3. I've got a very long list of requests and new features planned, so stay tuned for that, as well as updates to MacGourmet touch in the coming year!